Film Review: ‘Les Misérables’
Anne Hathaway. Photo courtesy of Universal Pictures.
Musical theatre fans of Les Misérables beware! The film you are about to see will resemble the famous musical in score only. To be sure, the text will be quite familiar and the song lyrics pretty much the same; but the epic narrative, based on Victor Hugo’s ground breaking novel of the same name, will resonate and quake with a power quite unlike anything you’ve witnessed on the stage. For Les Misérables the film lets you experience Hugo’s story of suffering and redemption not as a sung-through musical but as an epic drama that is acted first and sung second. You may leave the movie house preferring this or that version of this or that song, but I guarantee that you will leave having experienced Les Misérables in a totally different way. And if you experience the film as I did, you will feel emotionally spent and longing for more spiritual tales of ethical courage in the face of human failing and resolve.
Helena Bonham Carter, Isabelle Allen, and Sacha Baron Cohen. Photo courtesy of Universal Pictures.
The unique power of Les Misérables springs directly from the directing prowess of Tom Hooper, whose direction of The King’s Speech further proved his ability to summon forth superb performances from his actors. The ensemble work in Les Misérables is nothing short of remarkable, as Hooper gives each actor the space to embody his or her part fully, even though the show’s thoroughly musical style would seem to dictate a different approach. A result of this stylistic decision is that the story is never interrupted by a song or even enhanced by a song. Rather, the actors embody the story through the dynamics of their songs. For musical purists, this choice might prove difficult to bear, as all the songs lose that “show stopper” quality. Instead, they become simply melodic vehicles through which Hugo’s larger, more enduring tale is told.
an incredible accomplishment
At the center of the film and the musical is Jean Valjean, a poor 19th century French laborer who steals a loaf of bread to feed his sister’s child, and who must then spend the next 19 years of his life in prison. Upon his release, he is condemned to bear the mark of a violent man until his death. Overcome by his contempt for society, he steals again, only to once again face prison. Hugh Jackman of Wolverine fame plays Valjean with great intensity, not only capturing the protagonist’s spiritual journey but also the full spectrum of his emotional changes. Jackman brings the character’s inner conflict into wonderful focus during the scene with the Bishop of Digne after he offers Valjean gold and silver in exchange for his promise to lead a good life. Valjean’s rendition of “What Have I Done?” and “Who Am I?” bring this inner conflict into full focus. Then, after Valjean has long since left his hatred of society behind, we experience the character’s resolve in “Bring Him Home.” He will grant independence to his charge Cosette so that she can be with her young love Marius even though her independence will mean his own loneliness and loss.
Oscar winner Russell Crowe plays Valjean’s arch nemesis Javert. At times prison warden, at times law enforcement officer, Javert is Hugo’s embodiment of the legal system. Crowe brings all his many talents to the role, not least of which is his ability to invoke empathy even in the cruelest of personas. He captures not only Javert’s fierce determination but also—and most importantly—the character’s spiritual unraveling. His rendition of “Javert’s Suicide” though not as rich as stage Javerts might perform it, fills the screen with the character’s turmoil and doubt, allowing the viewer to empathize with a man who has dedicated his life to his sense of duty to the law, only to now see that man crumble as the law fails and tragedy ensues.
The supporting cast of actor/singers is equally impressive. Anne Hathaway’s performance as Fantine is gut-wrenching, helped in no small way by screenwriter William Nicholson’s depiction of Fantine’s slide into prostitution, during which we witness the literal selling off of her body bit by bit. By the time we experience her gripping “I Dreamed a Dream,” we fully appreciate what “now life has killed the dream I dreamed” means. Amanda Seyfried’s Cosette and Eddie Redmayne’s Marius give the young love interests the necessary chemistry, with Cosette’s “I Saw Him Once” galvanizing the bond and Marius’s “Empty Chairs at Empty Tables” deepening the valor of commitment. Aaron Tveit as the revolutionary leader Enjorlas combines the character’s passionate love of justice with his ability to rouse loyalty. Finally, Samantha Barks gives Eponine both earthiness and tender frailty, most apparent when she sings “On My Own.”
To be sure, Hooper’s decision to rely on the close up throughout most of the film gave the actors the opportunity to convey a range of changes in intention and emotion. This complexity of depiction allowed the actors to bring a great deal of subtlety into their performances. Hooper’s equally daring choice to have the actors sing live during filming not only gives the songs their sense of intimacy but also their honesty, as characters move back and forth between singing and speaking without missing a beat. These qualities disarm the viewer as they allow him or her to experience the film’s singing in a strangely unique way, not so much as one would experience a professional singer but as one would experience a person who sings.
Hugh Jackman. Photo courtesy of Universal Pictures.
As in the musical, with its stunning theatrical visuals, the film version of Les Misérables offers the viewer a plethora of computer generated spectacles. From the opening prison work scene where hundreds of convicts pull a frigate into a harbor docking bay using large hemp ropes to the aerial Escheresque views of the Paris ghetto, the cinematography re-enforces the film’s epic scope.
The cinematography, however, like the music and the singing and the acting, does not at any moment overshadow the film’s most powerful feature: its story. That narrative focus is what gives this celluloid version of Les Misérables its cathartic power. After viewing this film, even aficionados of the musical will better appreciate the human misery implied by the musical’s title. They will also more fully understand the ethical choices faced by the story’s various characters, and it is within that suffering and those choices that Hugo’s true genius as a writer lies. When Valjean chooses to turn himself in instead of allow another to go to prison for him, we feel his courage; when Fantine chooses to sacrifice herself body and soul for the love of her child, we know what it means to love another; and when Enjorlas and his fellow revolutionaries choose to die at the hands of the State rather than give up the justice of their cause, we experience what it means to believe in something greater than oneself.
If we can experience all those gifts of the soul in one epic film, how can anyone say that Les Misérables is not an incredible accomplishment? It is a film truly worth seeing.
Running Time: 2 hours and 38 minutes. Rated PG 13 for violence and adult situations.
Les Misérables is playing at theatres all over the greater metro area, but for a superb viewing I recommend the Avalon Theatre, 5612 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Washington, DC. Not only will its 1923 architecture give the film experience a credible frame but the movie theatre only history and its survival in the modern world adds a bit of local courage to the event.